Australian Police

Australian Police

The Thin Blue Line – Australian Police

About The Author


True Stories from the Life of a Forensic Investigator


Esther McKay served in the NSW Police Force for seventeen years, attaining the rank of Detective (technical) Senior Constable. She worked in Forensic Services for fifteen years, specialising in crime-scene examination and vehicle identification. She has a Diploma of Applied Science in Forensic Investigation (NSW Police) and was awarded the National Medal of service in 2001. Esther retired Medically Unfit, Hurt on Duty in 2001.

Esther was recipient of the 2003 – 2004 Australian Society of Authors mentorship program, where she worked with Gabrielle Lord on the manuscript of Crime Scene. She now lives in Sydney with her husband and two children.

Esther is a keen advocate for improving mental health conditions for sufferers of PTSD and is currently working on her second book.

The Trauma that Lingers
by Anne Fawcett – Sydney Morning Herald

Dark side … the strain of working in criminal forensics turned Esther McKay’s life into a nightmare.

A new book puts the stress endured by emergency workers under the microscope. Fatal motor vehicle accidents or drug overdoses barely warrant a mention in the papers these days. In a few short sentences we’re spared the gory details endured by the emergency services personnel at the scene.

But police, ambulance officers and fire-fighters don’t have the luxury of detachment. They may be extracting a mutilated body from a burnt-out car or informing parents they have lost a child. Those experiences can have long-term effects on the health of those working at the scene. Up to 20 per cent of emergency services personnel suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder.

Esther McKay – a former NSW Police forensic investigator and the author of Crime Scene: True Stories From the Life of a Forensic Investigator – wishes she had known about the condition earlier.

At the age of 23, McKay became one of the first female police officers to work in forensics.

“I wanted to do something more involved,” she says. “Forensic work involved investigating more serious crime scenes, preparing detailed statements, giving evidence in court. I thought it would be really rewarding.” But the training was minimal.

“I found myself at incredibly challenging crime scenes, with very little training and totally inadequate equipment. I was mostly working alone so I didn’t have someone to ask.”

As McKay’s confidence and skills developed she noticed a change in herself.

“Once I knew what I was doing I was able to take more notice of the actual crime scene, the smell, being alone with a dead body and the shock. I started to get a bit emotional, although I always held it in.”

McKay lost her sense of humour. She was often on call for weeks at a time, working around the clock. Her first marriage broke up. She turned to alcohol. It was the hours spent alone at home, rather than those spent at murder scenes, that McKay found most difficult to bear.

“I would lay awake at night. When I did sleep I had nightmares. I became jumpy and nervy and I couldn’t eat, the adrenaline was pumping through my system non-stop.”

She developed a phobia of the telephone, which she associated with bad news. She became irritable and prone to angry outbursts. Things got worse when she had children with her second husband.

“I couldn’t stop thinking about jobs I’d been to where children had been killed or injured. I was constantly worried that something would happen to them and I was very overprotective.”

Finally, a decade after the onset of symptoms, McKay suffered a breakdown. She was medically discharged from the police in 2001, after 17 years in the force, classified hurt in the line of duty. Her GP referred her to the post-trauma treatment program at St John of God Hospital in Burwood.

“For the first time I looked at my symptoms and why I had them and understood much better why I had become bitter and twisted and burdened.”

She learned techniques to control flashbacks.

McKay says she will never completely recover from her disorder, but she understands herself a lot better now. “I can see how it happens. A lot of police, for example, don’t want to tell their spouse what they’ve been through when they come home from work. So they have a few drinks, maybe a few too many, and everything simmers away. That’s why they call [post-traumatic stress disorder] speechless terror – people really can’t talk about it, and their families really go through hell.”


Post-traumatic stress disorder is an anxiety disorder resulting from exposure to traumatic situations. Symptoms include flashbacks, nightmares and involuntary thoughts about the experience. Sufferers have increased levels of arousal and may avoid anything that reminds them of the traumatic experience. Up to 25 per cent of trauma survivors develop chronic PTSD, with some of us more likely to develop it than others.

Clinical psychologist Dr Rachel Guthrie has studied risk factors for the development of PTSD in fire-fighters.

“Emergency service workers are at risk of developing PTSD because of the amount of trauma-exposure associated with their work,” she says.

Guthrie believes the likelihood of an individual developing PTSD is influenced by their proximity to the traumatic event and the duration of the trauma, as well as individual factors such as prior trauma exposure. Chronic exposure is a big risk factor as exposure to trauma over time has a cumulative effect. The most effective treatment for PTSD is cognitive behaviour therapy, which allows the sufferer to correct unhelpful thinking patterns and to face situations they might fear because of their association to the trauma.

PTSD treatment programs are offered by St John of God Hospital in Burwood. contact Dr Selwyn Smith on 9715 9215 and also available at Westmead Hospital on 9845 7979.


One thought on “About The Author

  • I hope Esther is doing well today. I’m interested in any information or statistics of PTSD being a delayed response. It’s really hard finding any information and once you’ve left the job, and particularly if it was some time ago there is zero support from the NSWP, that’s what I have found anyway.
    PTSD is actually really tough when it’s from Police work, so many traumas and places and things to avoid. I cannot imagine how Esther must have felt or how she dealt with it. I feel bad enough and I wasn’t exposed to as much as Esther.
    The term PTSD didn’t even exist in when I joined the job in the late 1980’s, it sure destroyed my life though and it was years after I left when I started struggling.
    I had no idea what was wrong with me for a looong time. Looking back it should have been obvious that I had CPTSD …….but thanks to the pathetic support available to serving and previously serving Police in the years I was there – nothing.
    There was no support back then after a bad day at work, it just wasn’t taken seriously. Like all Police, some of the jobs I attended were so horrific and the worst mistake was going to work at a section dealing with child sexual abuse. I know it’s no different to what all Police do but at least now they have support. I can’t believe there was nothing for us, may have well have been nothing anyway.
    I’m sure “choir practice” became common place for many.
    I’m glad I left, I grieved that job for a very long time. My life has never been the same and probably never will be.
    The available NSWP resources that I have found aren’t of any help.
    Anyway, that’s the way it is. Just sad that I really did give my life for that job and it means nothing.
    Thanks to Esther for sharing her story.

    Excuse my punctuation and grammar to anyone that stumbles across this.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *